Reviewed, sourced guidance
Check a tallow balm’s skin-effect claims
Direct answer
ASA/CAP says objective cosmetic efficacy claims need evidence. A claim that a product treats or prevents disease may be medicinal; cosmetics must not make disease-treatment claims. This page does not classify any named product.
Read the whole impression created by a product name, image, testimonial and supporting text.
Key takeaways
- Save the complete wording and surrounding images.
- Ask what evidence supports an objective benefit.
- Do not infer clinical evidence from ingredient similarity.
- Treat disease-treatment promises as a reason to check authoritative guidance.
Separate experience from an objective result
Words about how a product feels are different from measured claims about what it does.
ASA/CAP says objective beauty and efficacy claims need appropriate evidence. The likely consumer impression matters, including images and context.
Sources for this section: ASA/CAP AdviceOnline, beauty and cosmetics claims (updated 2 February 2026; observed 2026-09-25)
Notice disease-treatment wording
ASA/CAP guidance says cosmetic advertising must not make medicinal claims unless the relevant product has the required authorisation.
A product page that promises to cure, treat or prevent a condition should be checked against the applicable medicines and cosmetics rules. This guide does not make that classification.
Sources for this section: ASA/CAP AdviceOnline, beauty and cosmetics claims (updated 2 February 2026; observed 2026-09-25)OPSS and Department for Business and Trade, cosmetics on the Great Britain market (observed 2026-09-25)
Ask what the evidence actually tested
Ask whether evidence concerns the finished product, the exact claimed outcome and the people for whom the claim is made.
Evidence about one ingredient does not automatically prove the same effect for every finished formula.
Sources for this section: ASA/CAP AdviceOnline, beauty and cosmetics claims (updated 2 February 2026; observed 2026-09-25)
Next steps
- Save the claim and the page date.
- Use the label checklist to record the seller’s evidence response without scoring the product.